What's it really like dealing with a car accident and insurance claim in Malaysia when you're not at fault?

Question

Someone rear-ended me at a traffic light in PJ last month, clearly their fault, but the whole claim process has been so confusing. Do I claim from my own insurer or theirs? Third party knock-for-knock, own damage, police report, panel workshop, I'm lost. For those who've gone through a not-at-fault accident claim here, how does it actually work and what should I have done?

Uncle Kopitiam Ah Seng · Accepted Answer

Been through this twice, here's the actual flow when you're not at fault. First, at the scene, take photos of everything, both cars, positions, plates, the damage, and the other driver's details and their IC, and note if there are witnesses. You must make a police report within 24 hours at the nearest balai, and so must the other party, this is a legal requirement in Malaysia regardless of fault. For the claim you have two routes, either a third-party claim against the at-fault driver's insurer, or use your own comprehensive insurance and let your insurer chase theirs via the Knock-for-Knock agreement. If you have comprehensive cover, the cleanest way is often the Own Damage Knock-for-Knock claim through your own panel workshop, and because you're not at fault your No Claim Discount (NCD) is protected, but you MUST prove you're not at fault with the police report and evidence. Go through a panel workshop, not a random one, so the insurer processes it smoothly.

Relationship Kak Yasmin · Answer

Honestly if the damage is minor and both of you are decent people, sometimes a private settlement is faster and keeps everyone's premium and NCD clean, but only do it with proper documentation. When someone lightly tapped my bumper, we agreed on a workshop quote, they paid me via bank transfer, and we both signed a simple settlement letter stating no further claims. That said, this only works for clearly minor damage where you trust the estimate, for anything structural or if there's any injury you MUST go the police report and insurance route, no shortcuts. Injury changes everything, that's when you need a lawyer. Judge the severity honestly before deciding.

Auntie Confinement Poh · Answer

Protect your NCD at all costs, that's the hidden money. Your No Claim Discount can be up to 55% off your premium after years of no claims, and if you claim on your own policy at fault you lose it. But when you're genuinely not at fault and can prove it with the police report and the other party's admission or a clear scenario like a rear-end, your NCD stays intact even if you claim OD, because the insurer recovers from the other side. Make sure your insurer records it as a not-at-fault claim, follow up and check, because sometimes they process it wrongly and ding your NCD. I had to call and correct mine.

Civil Servant Encik Azman · Answer

Key thing people mess up, don't admit fault or sign anything at the scene, and don't accept cash settlement offers on the spot no matter how convincing they sound. The other driver may beg you to settle privately to protect their NCD, but if the damage turns out worse than it looks, you're stuck. Also beware of tow truck sharks that swarm accident scenes and Cari, they'll tow your car to a dodgy workshop and hold it hostage with inflated charges. Call your own insurer's hotline for their authorised tow, most have 24-hour assistance. Get everything documented and let the proper process handle it.

Relationship Kak Yasmin · Answer

Since you're clearly not at fault, look into a Third Party Property Damage claim directly against their insurer, because with a third-party claim you might get your car repaired at a workshop of your choice and even claim for loss of use, meaning compensation for the days you couldn't use your car. This route can pay more than the knock-for-knock own damage route, but it's slower and you may need to engage a runner or even a lawyer for bigger claims. When my car was hit and clearly not my fault, the third-party route got me a car rental reimbursement that my own OD claim wouldn't have. Weigh speed versus amount, OD is faster, third-party can be more complete.

Tax Uncle Chandran · Answer

One practical warning, the police report classification matters a lot. When you make your report, describe the accident clearly and factually so it's obvious the other party is at fault, because the insurer relies heavily on how the report reads. For a rear-end at a light, that's usually straightforward, the one behind is almost always liable. Keep a copy of your report, the other party's report if you can get it, and all photos. The whole process took me about 3-4 weeks with a panel workshop, some insurers are faster. Be patient but keep following up with your claims officer, squeaky wheel gets the oil here.

What's it really like dealing with a car accident and insurance claim in Malaysia when you're not at fault?

6 contributors answered

Answer this

Related questions

Landlord wants 3 months deposit plus utility deposit for a condo in PJ, is this legal and can I negotiate?

Renew roadtax online MyEG vs JPJ counter, which better?

What's it like to balik kampung during Raya/CNY, and how to survive the traffic?

Macam mana check dan bayar saman JPJ/PDRM online? Ada diskaun tak?

Got a summons for something I didn't do, how to dispute a traffic saman?

Company wants to terminate me but only gave 24 hours notice, what are my rights as an employee in Malaysia?